Forum discussions Who's online Member Birthdays

Post a reply

Write your message and submit
Tip: To insert a drawing, type the Drawing ID between the [drawing]123[/drawing] tag.
The drawing ID is the number at the end of your drawing URL.
E.g. ratemydrawings.com/drawings/cartoons/123.html
:) :| :( :D :o ;) :/ :P :lol: :mad: :rolleyes: :cool:

By posting you agree to our Behavior Policy.
Options

< Back to previous page

Topic review (newest first)

vespas22
06 Oct, 2012 2:59 am

http://www.ratemydrawings.com/drawings/ … 64528.html
Hi

Great site, slowing getting a little better with tools.

If you could find time to look at my drawings.

Thank you

red*rogue
25 Aug, 2012 9:50 am

thnx for the feedback c:

SPITS9
24 Aug, 2012 4:16 pm

***ATTENTION*** THERE WILL BE NO MORE FEEDBACK. THANKS TO ALL THE PARTICIPANTS. THIS THREAD IS CLOSED.

SPITS9
24 Aug, 2012 4:09 pm

red*rogue wrote:

awesome =w=
People rarely give criticism.
The only ones who did were my drawing teachers or my siblings =__=

http://fc05.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2012/ … 5bot1w.png

It's a bit of a huge drawing :'D. It was my latest semi-realism attempt. It's still in uhm... full development X'D
But I never look at any other semi-realistic works, I get jealous and look at my own poop and then I stop whatever I was working on :'D

oh and don't look at the words I wrote there. It would otherwise be really empty, but I never really intended them to be there :'D

hai ^^ Feedback: Same here, not much to add. It's still a work in progress. I'd watch the eyes. Good job on the hair. The shading seems to be working, watch the neck and the clothes tho. The ear could be a tad bigger.

The background could've been more desaturated, the focal point is the face. Wouldn't recommend adding too much fancy text effects, a mere suggestion. As for composition, try avoiding putting objects smack in the middle.  The rest seems to be off to a good start. All in all, quite promising. Thanks for your entry. ^^

SPITS9
24 Aug, 2012 3:52 pm

YesPlease wrote:

can i have another? ^_^;

i think this is my best work, so id like to see what i could do better. (: thanks!

http://www.ratemydrawings.com/drawings/ … 85856.html

hi there ^^ Feedback: The clothes could be more defined. Some of the shapes and folds need work. The head is too small in relation to the body, maybe fix the anatomy. The hands and arms are definitely off.
The hair needs to be bigger.

As for the shading, the shading is different from the original ref, dunno if that's on purpose.
It's recommended to keep the shading consistent. The background could use some work as well, the perspective is off and the windows on the buildings are too big. And some of the props in the bg are deformed, the lines should be quite straight. Some of the debris floating about is missing, details and such. Only add those when all the basic stuff is in place, icing on the cake.

Also, there aren't that much gradient effects. You added some. One of the reasons why the original is appealing as a whole is because of its simplistic 2d look and feel, adding too much gradient effects breaks that up. It can make it pop less.

The pallette in the background is more saturated, especially the blue. You're missing a couple of zeros with the time indication there and there seem to be more clouds. Might wanna fix that.

Hunted down the original for comparison:

http://fc08.deviantart.net/fs70/i/2011/ … 4g1mrs.png

All in all, nice attempt. Thanks for your entry. ^^

red*rogue
23 Aug, 2012 11:12 am

awesome =w=
People rarely give criticism.
The only ones who did were my drawing teachers or my siblings =__=

http://fc05.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2012/ … 5bot1w.png

It's a bit of a huge drawing :'D. It was my latest semi-realism attempt. It's still in uhm... full development X'D
But I never look at any other semi-realistic works, I get jealous and look at my own poop and then I stop whatever I was working on :'D

oh and don't look at the words I wrote there. It would otherwise be really empty, but I never really intended them to be there :'D

YesPlease
22 Aug, 2012 6:15 pm

can i have another? ^_^;

i think this is my best work, so id like to see what i could do better. (: thanks!

http://www.ratemydrawings.com/drawings/ … 85856.html

SPITS9
05 Aug, 2012 12:03 pm

Opal1024 wrote:

i would like some feedback on my most recent drawing. i'm trying to portray....i don't know how to say it exactly...i guess, like a feeling of hope/lifted spirits, or flying.
thanks a bunches!! smile

hi ^^ Feedback: Not too much to add to this one either. The foreground and background are working as a whole. The values in the background could've been more varied, the upper part could be darkened a bit more to contrast with the foreground. The clouds be more defined, same goes for the greenery.
At the moment it's really just 2 colours, wich is fine if that's specifically what you're going for. However, and as a suggestion, to add to the overal mood and the message, you could've added a sunset, for example. Just something to accentuate the feeling of hope/lifted spirits. Nothing too fancy tho, gotta keep the attention on the vocal point. The paper plane.

I'd recommend resizing the sun too, smaller? And have it fade out a bit.

Clouds Example:

http://image.shutterstock.com/display_p … 573218.jpg

http://pics4.city-data.com/cpicc/cfiles8375.jpg

Hills Example:

http://www.wallspedia.com/wallpapers/Au … n_5392.jpg
http://www.armin-grewe.com/holiday/scot … -hills.jpg

All in all, great start. And you're welcome. Thanks for your entry. ^^

SPITS9
05 Aug, 2012 11:36 am

Spirted Away wrote:

it's my best manga. Thanks spits

hai ^^ Feedback: Cute chibi. x3 The basic shading seems to be working. Minor suggestions here and there. Could've been cleaner in places. The eyes could use some work, try using similair values. And the eyebrows seem to be missing, eyebrows and facial expressions usually go hand in hand.

The lines could be more defined, they're a bit messy at the moment. Tip: The line tool.
Same goes for the hair and clothing.

Example:

http://www.absoluteanime.com/lucky_star/konata.jpg

The background could be more interesting as well, all up to you there. Mere suggestions.
All in all, nice start. Thanks for your entry. ^^

SPITS9
05 Aug, 2012 11:25 am

jeanette474 wrote:

http://www.ratemydrawings.com/drawings/inspiration/883945.html
\Would like some feedback on drawing portraits.  Did this one of Barack.

hi Jeanette ^^ This time the link seems to be working just fine, unlike your last post.
Feedback: Something i noticed right away is the narrowness of the proportions, Barack Obama is quite present, anatomically. The head's definitely wider, especially the top of the cranium. It's relatively broad in relation to the rest of the facial features. Pull up the supraorbital foramen. Same goes for the cheeckbones and jawline. The chin seems to be suffering too, at the moment it's more feminine, as opposed to masculine. Try broadening the chin up a bit.

Here's a simple anatomical tip, the corners of the mouth should line up with the the pupils of the eyeballs.
And some reference of the human cranium.

Anatomy:

http://face-and-emotion.com/dataface/ph … _front.jpg
http://face-and-emotion.com/dataface/ph … m_side.jpg

Furthermore, the sternocleidomastoideus muscle could be thicker. It's quite thin at the moment. Widen that neck up a bit. The rest of the facial features could use work too, pull out the nasolabial fold a bit more. One of the nostrils is bigger in comparison. The nose could be wider.  Good job on the ears.
I could go on about all the anatomy issues, but i'll switch to the shading from here.

Not sure if you were going for full-fledged realism or a simple value study.
As a whole, the shading could be pushed a bit. Both the values and the saturation could be pushed, try playing with those some more. The hair could be darker. Same goes for the presidential attire. Tie and suit.  As for the background, maybe add the national flag of the United States of America on a seperate layer.

All in all, nice drawing. Hope this helps. And yes, Barack Obama can be inspirational.
Thanks for your entry. ^^

SPITS9
05 Aug, 2012 10:48 am

Suteshii-chan wrote:


...not sooo bad?..i dont think..lol well feedback is still needed so mater how good or bad you are!! big_smile

hi ^^ Feedback: This one is good to go. tongue Some minor things here and there, the neck, folds and shadows. Try pushing the folds and shadows a bit more, a line isn't enough to accentuate the placement. Be bold. Also, background and foreground could've been seperated a bit more, if it's working as a thumbnail, it should work when the tip of your nose's up against it. Good job on the hair and the general facial expression. All in all, nice drawing. Thanks for your entry. ^^

SPITS9
05 Aug, 2012 10:37 am

YesPlease wrote:

http://www.ratemydrawings.com/drawings/manga-original/882919.html

-
listen, im actually afraid to do this. ive been unconfident lately, but like you said, jopefully i will become motivated.
-

i am very new to rmd, so i dont know how  to use tools very well. this is te first time i have actually tried drawing a house, or a very detailed background actually. shading is my weakness, so i would like tips on that especially. that and hair.

thanks so much (:

Hi there. Welcome to rmd. ^^ Feedback: Right off the bat, it's too flat. Here are some examples for illustration purposes:

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m2t38 … 1_1280.png
http://www.rubberslug.com/img_show.aspx … ction=Item

Try fixing the angles first and introducing a bit of depth and distance. Good job on the shadows. As for the the characters in the foreground, the pose could be pushed a bit more. Same goes for the palette. You mentioned you needed tips on shading and hair. Apart from the above, the lines on both characters seem quite simplistic, i recommend pushing those some more. Example: the clothing and hair. As for shading, it's not that bad actually. The basic 2 tones are working, maybe ease up on the gradient effect.

Here's an example:

http://www.wallpaperfox.com/download/vi … AyNC5qcGc=

http://static.desktopnexus.com/wallpape … 1344191650

Notice the difference in shading on the second example? I'd recommend keeping it simple at first and go from there.

All in all, nice start. Don't be afraid to improve. Hopefully this has been motivating. Thanks for your entry. ^^

SPITS9
05 Aug, 2012 9:39 am

minime12 wrote:

http://colorslive.com/halfs/000/024/421/_244217.jpg
Made it on a different website, and your last critique was so so helpful!

Hi, everyone.^^ Feedback: Same here, not much to add or seriously and constructively critique. The palette is working, maybe push the values a bit, they're getting lost in places. The hair definitely could've been more refined, as well as the eyes, nose and mouth. Not sure about the availability of the tools, as you mentioned you drew this on different site. All in all, nice drawing. And the movie's great, btw. Thanks for the entry. ^^

Opal1024
03 Aug, 2012 9:50 am

i would like some feedback on my most recent drawing. i'm trying to portray....i don't know how to say it exactly...i guess, like a feeling of hope/lifted spirits, or flying.
thanks a bunches!! smile

Spirted Away
03 Aug, 2012 4:35 am

it's my best manga. Thanks spits

Board footer

190 online members & visitors
See who's online
Follow us on:
RateMyDrawings on FacebookRateMyDrawings on YouTube RateMyDrawings on Twitter

Copyright Mixart New Media LLC.
As creators of drawings, you own the rights to your own drawings. Respect copyright protected artwork.
More information in our Terms and Copyright Policy.

About RateMyDrawings Terms & Conditions Advertise on RMD Privacy Policy Donate Behavior Guide